Blog
Best personal injury lawyer for Erb’s palsy
Best Personal Injury Lawyer for Erb’s Palsy – The Ultimate Guide
Introduction
When a child is born with Erb’s Palsy (a type of brachial plexus birth injury) due to someone else’s negligence—whether during pregnancy, delivery or neonatal care—the consequences can be lifelong: physical impairment, therapy needs, adaptive equipment, elevated care costs and changed life-opportunities. In such situations you don’t just need a standard injury lawyer—you need the best personal injury lawyer for Erb’s Palsy: one with deep experience in birth injury/medical negligence claims, familiar with brachial plexus cases, capable of handling complex medical evidence and securing full compensation for the child’s future. In this guide you’ll learn how to identify that lawyer, why Erb’s Palsy cases differ from many other personal injury claims, what key medical and legal issues you must understand, and why American Counsel should be your trusted partner. By the end you’ll be ready to proceed with clarity and confidence.
Understanding Erb’s Palsy
What Is Erb’s Palsy?
Erb’s Palsy—also called Erb-Duchenne palsy—is a condition caused by injury to the upper brachial plexus nerves (which connect the spinal cord to the shoulder, arm and hand), typically during birth. The injury can lead to weakness or paralysis in the arm, loss of function, and in some cases permanent disability. Gluckstein LLP+2Sokolove Law+2
According to one law firm’s description: “Erb’s Palsy is one of the most common types of birth injury, affecting one or two children out of every 1,000 births… It is caused by damage to the brachial plexus… This condition causes muscle weakness, loss of function and sometimes causes sensory issues.” Gluckstein LLP
Common Causes & Typical Scenarios
Erb’s Palsy may occur when there is mis-management of delivery, such as:
Excessive pulling/traction on the baby’s head, neck or shoulders during delivery, stretching or tearing the brachial plexus nerves. Passen Powell Jenkins I Trial Lawyers+1
Shoulder dystocia (where the baby’s shoulder becomes stuck behind the mother’s pubic bone) and the physician fails to act appropriately (for example by delay in a C-section or improper manoeuvres). Passen Powell Jenkins I Trial Lawyers+1
Large birth weight baby, difficult delivery, failure to monitor or plan for risk which leads to nerve injury. jjsjustice.com+1
Why It Matters So Much
Erb’s Palsy claims are distinct and serious because:
The injury often requires long-term rehabilitation, possibly surgeries, therapy, adaptive equipment, and may limit arm/hand function for life. Porter Law Group+1
The future care and cost implications can be substantial—monitoring, corrective surgeries, occupational therapy, lost earning capacity in adulthood.
Medical and legal complexity is higher than many “ordinary” injury cases—birth records, obstetric standards of care, neonatal monitoring, expert neurology/orthopaedic input.
A good outcome requires choosing a lawyer who understands the lifelong nature of the injury, not just the immediate effects.
Because of all these factors, selecting the right lawyer is critically important.
Key Aspects / Components of an Erb’s Palsy Personal Injury Claim
1. Medical Evidence, Severity & Long-Term Outlook
It is essential to define what injury the child has: which nerves are damaged, arm/hand function status, whether recovery is expected, whether surgeries are required, whether the impairment is partial or complete.
Collect full medical records: prenatal care, labour/delivery records, neonatal records, imaging, therapy records, surgical reports (if any). One firm emphasises “You need an experienced medical malpractice attorney who can investigate the causes of your child’s injury and obtain necessary medical records, including the child’s birth or delivery records and the mother’s delivery records.” lombardiandlombardi.com
Prognosis: Will the child require ongoing therapy? Will arm/hand function be permanently limited? Will future surgeries or adaptive devices be needed? The lawyer must consider all these future costs.
Early lawyer involvement: Because records (fetal-monitoring strips, delivery room logs, equipment used) may become more difficult to retrieve over time, early action is beneficial.
2. Damages & Compensation
In an Erb’s Palsy claim you may seek compensation for:
Past medical/therapy costs: surgeries, hospital stays, therapies (physical/occupational), adaptive devices.
Future medical/rehab costs: corrective surgeries, further therapy, home/work adaptations, assistive devices, monitoring.
Lost future earning capacity: if the child’s arm/hand function is impaired and limits future work ability, or if significant time is needed for therapy instead of education or training.
Pain, suffering & non-economic damages: impairment of life’s quality, functional limitations, emotional impact on child and family.
Other costs: home modifications, transportation for treatment, caregiver time, special schooling or adaptations.
A specialist lawyer will build a claim that reflects the full lifetime impact, not just immediate bills.
3. Liability & Legal Strategy
Duty and breach: Identify who owed a standard of care (obstetrician, delivery team, hospital) and how they breached it (e.g., failed to act on shoulder dystocia, applied undue traction, failed to plan for large baby).
Causation: You must show that the breach caused the injury to the brachial plexus rather than a congenital anomaly or unavoidable event. Expert neurology/obstetric testimony is often required. For example, one article notes: “Erb’s Palsy is often caused by a healthcare professional’s failure to respond to a difficult delivery properly or punctually.” Sokolove Law
Preservation of evidence: Delivery logs, fetal monitoring strips, nurse/doctor notes, hospital policy, equipment logs—all need to be secured. Delay may jeopardize your claim. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Attorneys+1
Settlement vs trial: Because future costs may be large and liability may be contested, you want a lawyer who is prepared to go to trial if necessary—not just settle early for less.
Statute of limitations/time-limits: Legal deadlines apply; you must act within the timeframe in your jurisdiction. Missing the deadline may bar the case entirely. Porter Law Group
4. The Role of a Specialist Lawyer
When choosing your lawyer for an Erb’s Palsy case, look for one who:
Has specific experience in birth injury/medical malpractice claims involving brachial plexus and Erb’s Palsy—not just general personal injury law.
Understands the medical/rehab landscape: nerve injury, surgeries, therapy, adaptive devices, long-term functional outcomes.
Works with expert networks: obstetricians, neonatologists, neurologists/orthopaedic surgeons, physical/occupational therapy, life-care planners.
Communicates clearly and compassionately—such cases impact families deeply.
Offers a contingency or “no win, no fee” arrangement (where permitted) so your family is not burdened with upfront legal costs. For example one birth injury firm states they work “on contingency-fee basis, so you don’t pay anything unless you win.” Porter Law Group
Legal Implications & Professional Guidance
Why Professional Legal Guidance Matters
Erb’s Palsy claims are inherently more complex than many straightforward injury claims. Without the right legal support you risk:
Settling too early before the full future costs and life-impact are known—resulting in under-compensation.
Failing to preserve key evidence (delivery monitoring logs, hospital notes) which may be lost or destroyed.
Having the hospital/defendant argue that the injury was unavoidable or not due to negligence—thus you need a lawyer who can resist that defence.
Missing deadlines and being barred from claiming.
Legal guides emphasise that “you may be eligible for compensation” and prompt legal review is recommended. Sokolove Law
Key Legal Factors to Review
When selecting your lawyer and proceeding with a claim, consider:
Time-Limits/Statute of Limitations: How long you have to bring the claim. These vary by jurisdiction.
Pre-existing conditions or independent causation: If the child had a condition before birth or other causes of nerve injury, the claim may be more complicated. Your lawyer should review thoroughly.
Evidence Preservation: Are delivery/fetal monitoring records retained? Are doctors/hospital cooperative? Early action helps.
Valuation of Future Losses: The lawyer must assess not just what has happened, but what will happen—future surgeries, therapy, work/earning capacity, quality of life.
Settlement vs Litigation Strategy: Make sure the lawyer is willing to litigate if needed—not just take the first settlement.
Selecting the Right Lawyer: Ask: “How many Erb’s Palsy/birth-injury cases have you handled? What were results? What experts will you use? How will you value future needs? What fees are involved?”
When to Contact a Lawyer
As soon as you suspect your child’s Erb’s Palsy may have been caused (or aggravated) by negligent care during birth or delivery. Early legal advice helps preserve your rights.
If your child is diagnosed with Erb’s Palsy and you believe that delivery problems (shoulder dystocia, improper traction, delayed C-section) occurred.
If you feel the hospital or doctor may be liable and you want to evaluate your options.
If you are being approached by hospital risk management or asked to sign documents—seek legal advice first.
If you want to ensure that the future costs for your child (therapy, adaptive equipment, lost earnings) will be properly considered in any claim.
Common Challenges & How to Overcome Them
Challenge 1: Future Costs Not Immediately Clear
Often the full impact (surgeries, therapy, work limitation) is not known early on.
Solution: Choose a lawyer who builds your claim around future needs, not just immediate treatment.
Challenge 2: Medical Causation & Standard of Care
The hospital may claim the nerve injury was unavoidable. Proving negligence is challenging.
Solution: Your lawyer should engage obstetric/neonatal and neurology experts to establish breach and causation.
Challenge 3: Loss or Delay of Evidence
Records may be lost, or monitoring strips discarded, making proof difficult.
Solution: Act early. Choose a lawyer who knows how to preserve evidence and request records promptly.
Challenge 4: Emotional Impact & Family Stress
Families caring for a child with Erb’s Palsy often face emotional, physical and financial stress.
Solution: A lawyer who communicates compassionately, explains clearly and helps you focus on your child and family while they handle the legal process.
Challenge 5: Selecting the Wrong Lawyer
If you choose a lawyer without Erb’s Palsy/birth injury/medical negligence experience, your claim may be undervalued or mishandled.
Solution: During consultation ask for specific birth-injury/Erb’s Palsy case examples, results, what expert team they use, their fees. Only choose one with proven experience.
Step-by-Step Guide / Best Practices
Here is a practical roadmap if your child has (or you suspect they have) Erb’s Palsy and you’re seeking the right lawyer and plan to proceed.
Step 1: Seek Medical Assessment & Document Everything
Ensure your child is being evaluated by an appropriate specialist (paediatric neurologist, orthopaedic surgeon specialising in brachial plexus injuries).
Keep all medical records: birth/delivery records, neonatal records, therapy records, imaging, surgeries, follow-ups.
Photograph and document your child’s arm/hand: function, asymmetry, difference in size, range of motion.
Maintain a diary/journal of how the injury affects your child: therapy sessions, limitations, milestones missed, costs incurred.
Step 2: Preserve Evidence & Gather Key Documentation
Request hospital/delivery centre to preserve fetal monitoring strips, delivery room logs, any documentation of shoulder dystocia or traction used.
Collect names of the care providers: obstetrician, anesthesiologist, nurses, midwife; note what happened during delivery (shoulder dystocia, vacuum extraction, forceps, C-section decision).
Retain receipts/invoices: therapies, surgeries, adaptive devices, transportation to treatment, lost work for parents if applicable.
If possible, photograph delivery equipment or surroundings (if relevant) and record witness names (if any) who observed the delivery.
Step 3: Hire a Specialist Personal Injury Lawyer
Use the checklist:
Does the lawyer have specific experience with Erb’s Palsy / brachial plexus birth injury / medical-malpractice cases?
Can they provide examples or outcomes of previous cases?
Do they work with appropriate medical experts (obstetrician, neonatologist, neurologist, orthopaedic surgeon, life-care planner)?
Are they willing to go to trial if necessary (not just settle early)?
Do they offer a free consultation, clear explanation of fees (contingency/no win-no fee) so you are not burdened upfront?
At your consultation ask: “How many Erb’s Palsy or brachial plexus birth injury cases have you handled? What were the results? What experts will you bring? How will you value my child’s future needs, therapy, education, adaptive equipment, lost earnings? What are your fees?”
Choose a lawyer you feel comfortable communicating with, who listens, explains clearly, and shows real expertise in these types of cases.
Step 4: Develop Your Legal Strategy & Build Your Claim
Your lawyer investigates liability: what happened during pregnancy/delivery/newborn care, what standard of care was expected, what was breached, and how that caused the injury.
They engage experts: obstetric/neonatal care, neurology/orthopaedics, life-care planning (future therapy, equipment, home modifications), vocational/earning capacity (if adult outcome relevant).
They build the claim: past & future medical/therapy/adaptive costs, lost earning potential, pain & suffering/quality-of-life loss, family/caregiver impact.
They negotiate with the hospital/medical provider/insurer; if settlement offers are inadequate, they prepare for filing suit/trial.
They will keep you informed: milestone updates, what to expect, what your role is (providing records, medical follow-ups, therapy progress).
Step 5: Monitor Child’s Progress & Update Your Claim
Because Erb’s Palsy may evolve and long-term impact might become clearer as your child grows, your lawyer should revise your claim to reflect emerging needs (further surgery, therapy upgrades, adult limitations).
Avoid settling too early if future needs and costs are not yet known. A seasoned lawyer will advise when the appropriate time is to actually settle.
Continue documenting: new therapies, new surgeries, how the injury affects schooling, social/athletic involvement, additional costs incurred.
Step 6: Settlement or Trial & Post-Resolution Planning
Before you accept any settlement, make sure it covers future needs: ongoing therapy, adaptive equipment, home/vehicle modifications, possible job/earning limitations, caregiver support—not only immediate past costs.
If trial is required: ensure your lawyer has expert witness readiness, medical expert testimony, a litigation plan.
After resolution: plan how to use the compensation: life-care planning, trust funds, special education support, long-term adaptive strategy. A good lawyer will guide you through what comes after the settlement—not just fight for the payment.
Why Choose American Counsel
When you’re dealing with an Erb’s Palsy claim, you cannot afford to hire a law firm that treats your case like a “routine injury”. Here’s why American Counsel stands out:
Specialised Expertise in Birth Injury & Brachial Plexus / Erb’s Palsy Claims: We understand the unique nature of brachial plexus/birth-nerve injuries—the delivery mechanisms, the long-term therapy/rehab implications, the functional/earning-capacity impact—and build your claim accordingly.
Authoritative Resource & Trusted Partner: We position ourselves not just as your lawyer but as your guide—helping you understand what your child’s condition means for their future, what rights you have, what experts are needed, and what compensation you should seek.
Holistic & Client-Centred Approach: We recognise that Erb’s Palsy affects not just the child’s arm—but mobility, independence, school, sports, job potential, family life—and craft a strategy around that full spectrum.
Trial-Ready Advocacy & Proven Resources: Because Erb’s Palsy claims often involve contested medical-malpractice, long-term costs, and complex liability, we bring expert networks, strong negotiation AND litigation readiness—not just quick settlement.
Focus on Your Child’s Long-Term Future: We emphasise not just what has happened but what lies ahead: therapy, education, adaptive equipment, employment potential—and ensure your compensation reflects that future.
If your child has been diagnosed with Erb’s Palsy and you believe it may have been the result of negligent care during birth or neonatal period, contact American Counsel now. Our specialised team is ready to evaluate your rights, map your child’s future needs and fight for the full compensation and protection you deserve.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1. Do I need a lawyer for an Erb’s Palsy claim?
A: Yes—If your child has been diagnosed with Erb’s Palsy and you believe it resulted from negligent care during birth or delivery (for example shoulder dystocia, improper traction or delayed C-section) then a specialised medical-malpractice/birth-injury lawyer is highly advisable. General injury lawyers may lack the specialized knowledge needed for such claims. For example, legal resources on Erb’s Palsy state the condition “is often caused by a health care professional’s failure to respond to a difficult delivery properly or punctually.” Sokolove Law
Q2. How much is an Erb’s Palsy claim worth?
A: There is no fixed amount—value depends on severity of nerve damage, arm/hand function, need for surgery, therapy, long-term care/adaptive equipment, age of child, future earning capacity, quality of life impairment. Legal webinars highlight that settlements can be in the millions for serious birth injuries. jjsjustice.com+1
Q3. What kind of evidence is needed?
A: You’ll need: birth/delivery/neonatal records, documentation of shoulder dystocia or traction, fetal monitoring records, imaging/nerve studies, therapy/treatment records, expert opinions linking the injury to the delivery breach. Many Erb’s Palsy law-sites emphasise getting birth records and expert review. lombardiandlombardi.com
Q4. What if the hospital says Erb’s Palsy was unavoidable?
A: Then you will need a lawyer experienced in birth injury/medical negligence who can review the full medical records, engage obstetric/neonatal/nerve-injury experts, and build an argument of breach of standard of care + causation. A lawyer should explain that not all cases are negligence—but some are and require expert analysis.
Q5. Will I have to go to court to get full compensation?
A: Not always—but because Erb’s Palsy claims can involve large future costs and complex medical evidence, you should choose a lawyer who is prepared for trial if necessary—not just one who pushes a quick settlement. For example, birth-injury attorneys emphasise they will “help you get the best possible result from an injury claim” and provide free consultations. The Barnes Firm
Q6. How long will this process take?
A: It depends on the complexity: severity of the injury, future therapy/rehab needs, age of the child, liability clarity, number of defendants, whether settlement or trial. Some birth injury claims take months or even years. A lawyer should give you a realistic timeline based on your case.
Q7. What happens after I receive compensation?
A: You’ll need to plan how to use it: long-term therapy/adaptive equipment, home/vehicle modifications, education/training, financial management for future care, possibly job/training support. A good lawyer should help you think about what comes next—not just fight for the payment.
Conclusion
Erb’s Palsy caused by someone else’s negligence during birth or delivery is not just a nerve injury—it is a lifelong condition with medical, functional, educational, vocational, emotional and financial consequences. The medical and legal complexities are high, the future care needs are serious, and choosing the best personal injury lawyer for Erb’s Palsy is one of the most important decisions you’ll make. You need a legal partner who understands not just the injury to the arm—but the long-term therapy, adaptive needs, education/employment implications, family impact, and is ready to fight for your child’s future—not just a settlement today. For anyone facing this challenge, American Counsel stands out as the authoritative legal resource you can trust—specialised, experienced, client-centred and ready to fight for your full rights and compensation. Don’t face this alone. Take the next step: contact American Counsel and begin building your path to justice, support and long-term protection.